Gary L. Huber, MD
ANA Vice President for Scientific Communications and Director
Texas Nutrition Institute
In the United States, in addition to its use in cooking and food
preparation, garlic is now second in sales only to Echinacea as a
best selling herbal supplement. As it grows in popularity, mixed reports
and controversy continue to surround claims of its medicinal properties.
It has been, in fact, probably the most studied herbal product, with
about 1,200 medical and pharmacological reports, and an additional
700 or so chemical studies, now published. With that much scientific
attention, one would think that we would be able to sort out clearly
fact from myth.
Generally, garlic has been so extensively domesticated over so many
thousands of years that there no longer are wild forms found anywhere
in nature related to the type of garlic humans now use. It is believed
that as a variant of the lillie family of plants it originated probably
somewhere in Central Asia, and spread rapidly in all directions --
westward to the Mediterranean, eastward throughout China, and southward
into India. In all of these areas it has since the beginning of recorded
time been used as both a food and a medicinal product.
Indeed, garlic has been employed for medicinal purposes by more
cultures over more millennia than any other plant product or substance.
The first recorded use was by the Sumerians of Mesopotamia, in the
now Mid-East regions of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers.
Garlic was of great medicinal importance in nearby Egypt. It has
been found in the tombs of the ancient Pharaohs dating back to 3,200
B.C. Its use by the pyramid builders, who believed garlic gave them
strength, is inscribed on the Great Pyramid of Cheops. The only slave
revolt in Egypt (beside the Jewish Exodus) was by laborers over a
lack of garlic one year when the Nile flooded the garlic fields. In
the Egyptian "Ebers Codex," written in 1550 B.C., there
were 22 different medical formulations that included garlic.
The ancient Israelites were fond of garlic long before Moses led
them out of Egypt. In the Mishnah, a collection of Jewish traditions
incorporated into the Talmud, the ancient Hebrew writers refer to
themselves as "the garlic eaters." In the Bible (Numbers
11:5), still on their way to the Promised Land, the Jews lamented
the absence of garlic, as well as other foods from Egypt.
Today, nearly 70 variants of garlic grow in the Holy Land. The widespread
dissemination of garlic around the world is attributed, in part, to
the Jewish diaspora.
The Greeks used garlic to bring strength to their athletes at the
Olympic games and in other contests, and employed it, as well, to
help heal battle wounds. Hippocrates, who lived 460 to 370 B.C. and
is considered the father of western medicine, recommended garlic for
pneumonia and other infections, for cancer and for digestive disorders,
as well as a diuretic to increase the flow of urine and a substance
to improve menstrual flow.
Another Greek, Dioscorides, who lived in the first century A.D.
and is held in esteem as the founder of the modern pharmacy, dispensed
garlic to treat rabid dog bites, snake bites, infections, bronchitis
and cough, leprosy, and clogged arteries, as well as other conditions.
The ancient Romans carried the garlic medicinal practices of the
Greeks forward. Galen (129-199 A.D.), personal physician to the Roman
Emperor Marcus Aurelius, and whose writings were to influence Arabic
and western medicine for over the next thousand years, called garlic
"the theriac of the peasants," an inexpensive near "cure
all" for a wide variety of almost countless ailments.
In the Middle Ages, a German nun, St. Hildegard of Bingen, who wrote
two medical textbooks, advocated raw garlic to heal the sick. The
London College of Physicians recommended garlic for the great plague
in 1665. A leading English physician, Sydenham, also used garlic about
the same time to cure small pox.
As more science began to enter the picture, Louis Pasteur demonstrated,
in 1858, that garlic could kill infectious germs. Albert Schweizer,
in the early and mid-20th century, used garlic in Africa to cure typhoid
fever and cholera
Garlic was used throughout World War I to treat battle wounds and
to cure dysentery. During World War II, garlic was known as "Russian
penicillin" because it was so effective in treating wound infections
when adequate antibiotics were not available.
So, where does that leave us today? Multiple scientific studies
indicate that garlic can lower cholesterol and triglycerides levels,
improve the outcome of coronary heart disease, reduce high blood pressure,
improve claudication (leg muscle cramps on exertion), prolong infant
feeding time for breast nursing, reduce or cure the fungal infection
of Athlete's foot, and reverse some middle ear inflammation. And,
it can do much more. There may even be some value, in addition, for
garlic in the potential reductions of certain cancers, especially
those of the colon and stomach.
Against this extraordinarily long and consistent history of garlic
as a useful medicinal product, there continue to occur "negative"
reports and healthy skepticism. Why are there discrepancies and why
do serious questions about its medicinal value still remain?
Currently, there are at least five different forms of garlic that
are widely marketed. Whole fresh garlic is rich in alliin (converted
to allicin when garlic is chopped) and ajoene, the two chemical constituents
thought to be most important to health. A daily dose of 1 to 3 cloves
of whole fresh garlic is needed to promote health.
Dried garlic powder, when standardized by allicin potential to whole
garlic, may also be beneficial. About 500 to 900 milligrams (with
an equivalent 5,000 micrograms of allicin), however, are needed to
be effective.
Steam-distilled garlic oil and oil macerates of garlic are readily
available in several products, but the effective medicinal dose (if
any) is not known.
Aged garlic extracts are also available, but again the effective
medicinal dose (if any) is not known and most likely is extremely
high.
Unfortunately, most of the scientific studies on these processed
garlic products have not controlled for the content of the active
constituents needed to assure health. Thus, as long as this lack of
standardization continues to occur, scientific reports will continue
to produce a "mixed bag" of results and some degree of controversy
will be perpetuated.
So, is garlic beneficial to your health? Most likely it is, if we
can learn anything from this long medicinal history. But, remember
that the vast majority of positive observations of the past were based
on the consumption of fresh whole garlic and plenty of it, at that!